Medigap Premiums in Rockford, IL: What Drives the Price

There is no single Medigap price for Rockford. Your monthly premium depends on the plan letter, your age when you buy, how the insurer prices policies, and a handful of discounts. The same Plan G can cost very different amounts from one insurer to the next, because the coverage is identical and only the price changes. That is why a local Medicare agent who can line up the same plan letter from several insurers saves most people more than any rule of thumb. At Almond Insurance in Rockford, comparing plans is what we do all day, and consumers do not pay us directly for that guidance.
Below you will find the national numbers, what they mean for a Rockford household, and a step-by-step way to compare quotes.
TL;DR
- Medigap is a separate monthly premium paid to a private insurer, on top of your Medicare Part B premium. Medicare does not pay it, and it usually rises every year (Medicare.gov).
- Nationally, the average Medigap premium was $244 a month in 2025. Plan G averaged $194 a month (KFF).
- Each plan letter gives the same benefits from every company, so compare Plan G with Plan G, not with Plan N.
- Your best price window is the six months after you enroll in Part B, when insurers must sell you a policy without health questions.
Table of Contents
- What Medigap actually costs
- National averages, and how to read them for Rockford
- Why the same plan costs different amounts
- Compare the right way: same letter, different companies
- When you can buy, and when health questions apply
- What Medigap premiums do not cover
- How we help Rockford households
- FAQ
- Sources
What Medigap actually costs
Medigap, also called Medicare Supplement, is private insurance that helps pay your share of costs that Original Medicare leaves behind, such as deductibles and coinsurance. Medicare.gov states that you pay the insurer a monthly premium, and you also keep paying your Part B premium. You must have Part B to keep a Medigap policy (Medicare costs, 2026).
So your monthly budget has two lines, not one:
- The Part B premium, paid to Medicare.
- The Medigap premium, paid to your insurer.
For the full Medicare cost picture, including deductibles and caps, see our guide to Medicare costs in 2026.
National averages, and how to read them for Rockford
KFF’s October 2026 report puts the average monthly Medigap premium across all current policyholders at $244 in 2025, or $2,926 a year. State averages ranged from $214 in Hawaii to $306 in New York (KFF). By plan, KFF reports:
| Plan | 2025 average monthly premium | Range across states |
|---|---|---|
| All Medigap policies | $244 | $214 (Hawaii) to $306 (New York) |
| Plan G | $194 | $164 (New Mexico) to $257 (New York) |
| Plan F | $325 | $243 (Vermont) to $378 (Nebraska) |
Two cautions about these figures. First, they average everyone who already holds a policy, including people who bought years ago and people of all ages. A 65-year-old shopping today may see a lower or higher number. Second, they are national and state-level, not Rockford quotes. Think of them as a ballpark that shows how wide the spread is, not as a promise for your ZIP code.
The trend matters just as much as the level. KFF reports that average premiums rose 7% between 2024 and 2025, about $192 more per year, and 20% from 2020 to 2025. Plan G rose 13% in the latest year and 38% over the five years. When you pick a policy, you are really picking a price path, not just a starting number.
For a Rockford-specific walk-through, our page on Medicare Supplement cost in Rockford goes into local detail, and Medigap costs in 2026 covers the general picture.

Why the same plan costs different amounts
Medigap is a federal idea regulated state by state. KFF explains that although Medicare is federal, states set the rules for how insurers price Medigap. That is why the same plan letter can carry very different premiums in different states, and why two Rockford neighbors can pay different amounts for the same coverage.
Your age and the rating method
Insurers use one of three pricing methods, according to KFF and a federal HHS report:
- Community rating: everyone in an area pays about the same, regardless of age.
- Issue-age rating: the premium is based on your age when you buy and does not rise because you get older (it can still rise with inflation and claims).
- Attained-age rating: the premium is based on your current age, so it climbs as you age.
KFF notes that 37 states and D.C. allow any rating system, nine states require community rating for people 65 and older, and four (Arizona, Florida, Georgia and Missouri) permit issue-age but prohibit attained-age rating. Illinois is among the states that allow any of them, so in Rockford the rating method of each policy is something to ask about. A federal HHS report found attained-age rating was the most common method nationally and lets insurers raise premiums nearly every year as you age (ASPE/HHS). That report is from 2011, so treat it as an explanation of how the method works, not as current market share.
A policy that looks cheapest at 65 can cost more than a slightly pricier one by 75. Ask each quote how the premium changes at 66, 70 and 75.
Where you live
Quotes are based on a regional ZIP code. The Illinois SHIP guide for the Chicago area explains that its rate charts list the companies licensed to sell each plan in Illinois and approximately what they charge by age at purchase (Illinois Department on Aging, SHIP). Rockford sits in a different region from Chicago, so your quotes will use your own ZIP.
Discounts and underwriting
Medicare.gov lists the things that can change what you pay (Get Medigap costs):
- Discounts some insurers offer to women, non-smokers, married people, or people who pay yearly or by electronic funds transfer, or who hold multiple policies.
- Medical underwriting, where the insurer reviews your health history, which is allowed outside your protected enrollment windows.
- Medicare SELECT policies, which can have lower premiums but require you to use certain providers.
- High-deductible options.
KFF adds that premiums may reflect age, smoking status, gender and residential area even during open enrollment and guaranteed-issue periods.
Compare the right way: same letter, different companies
This is the most useful fact in this article. Medicare.gov states that benefits in each lettered Medigap plan are the same no matter which company sells it, so price is the only difference between policies with the same letter. It recommends comparing Plan G with Plan G across companies, because premiums can differ widely.
Illinois follows the same standardized structure. The Illinois Department on Aging’s 2026 Medicare Choices Guide says Medigap policies must follow a standard benefit structure by law, and that plans A through N are currently sold. Plans F and G are also offered as high-deductible options, and Medicare SELECT is an option too (Medicare Choices Guide for 2026).

The plan letter itself matters. KFF reports that in 2025 Plan G was the most popular at 46% of policyholders and Plan F second at 30%, and that Plan F has not been available to newly eligible beneficiaries since 2020. If you are new to Medicare, Plan G and Plan N are typically the letters people weigh against each other. Our page on the high-deductible Plan G shows how that version trades a lower premium for a deductible.
A simple five-step comparison
- Pick the plan letter first. Decide which benefits you want, then price only that letter.
- Get quotes for your exact profile. Give your age, ZIP code, and whether you use tobacco. Medicare.gov cautions that estimated costs shown in comparison tools are only estimates and that each company sets its own premium, so confirm the real price with the insurer.
- Ask for the rating method. Community, issue-age or attained-age decides how fast the price climbs.
- Ask which discounts apply. Household, payment method and multi-policy discounts vary by insurer.
- Check the insurer’s history. Ask how often and by how much that company has raised premiums on the plan.
This routine is easy to describe and slow to do alone across a dozen insurers. We compare Medicare Advantage and Medicare Supplement plans for Rockford-area clients and walk through the results in plain language. You can see how that works on our plan comparison page.
When you can buy, and when health questions apply
Price and approval both depend on timing.
Your six-month window. The Illinois guide states that the federal Medigap open enrollment period starts when you first enroll in Part B. It lasts six months, and insurers must sell you a policy with no underwriting and cannot deny coverage. After it closes, insurers outside special protections may accept or reject applications (ASPE/HHS). The same HHS report describes seven guaranteed-issue situations, such as a Medicare Advantage plan leaving Medicare, employer or union coverage ending, or moving out of a SELECT service area. Our guide to Medigap guaranteed issue rights explains them.
Under 65 on Medicare. The NAIC’s state summary chart shows Illinois is one of five states requiring insurers to offer the same Medigap plans to people under 65 who are first eligible for Part B, with some limits on premiums (NAIC, as of February 2024).
The Illinois Birthday Law. If you are 65 to 75 and already have a Medicare supplement policy, Illinois gives you a 45-day open enrollment period starting on your birthday each year. You may buy a policy with equal or lesser benefits from the same company or an affiliate (Medicare Choices Guide for 2026). It lets current policyholders move to a different plan with the same insurer, which is useful when your premium has crept up. It applies to the same company, not to switching insurers.
KFF also notes that Blue Cross Blue Shield of Illinois sells Medigap to anyone 65 or older without underwriting as a company practice, not a legal requirement. Because practices like this can change, confirm the current policy when you shop.
What Medigap premiums do not cover
Medigap policies sold today cannot include prescription drug benefits, because drug coverage moved to Medicare Part D in 2006 (Illinois SHIP guide). If you take regular medications, budget for a separate Part D plan. We offer a Part D prescription review to check that your medications are covered. If you are managing a long-term condition, it also helps to understand how Medicare treats diagnostic testing. One example is this explainer on Medicare coverage for fibromyalgia testing, which shows how coverage questions affect your ongoing costs.
On a tight budget, Illinois also has the Medicare Savings Program, which can help with Medicare costs for people who qualify.
How we help Rockford households
Almond Insurance is a Medicare agency in Rockford, serving Northern Illinois and Southern Wisconsin. We compare Medicare Supplement, Medicare Advantage and Part D plans, support enrollment, and review coverage every year. Our approach is family-focused and jargon-free: we explain the options step by step so you know why a plan fits before you choose it.
If you are turning 65, we can start with your timeline through new-to-Medicare guidance. If you already have a policy, an annual review is the moment to ask whether your premium is still competitive. You can see how we handle Medicare Supplement and Medigap or contact us through our main site.

Caregivers are welcome too. If you are helping a parent sort through bills and renewal letters, you can ask us questions without enrolling in anything.
FAQ
Does Medigap cost anything?
Yes. You pay a monthly premium to the private insurer, and you also keep paying your Part B premium. Medicare does not pay your Medigap premium, and premiums typically increase each year (Medicare.gov).
What is a typical Medigap premium?
KFF reports a national average of $244 a month in 2025 across all policyholders, and $194 a month for Plan G. Your own Rockford quote depends on your age, ZIP code, tobacco use, rating method and the insurer, so get quotes for your exact profile.
Why did my Medigap premium go up?
Medigap premiums change for several reasons, including your age under attained-age rating, medical cost trends and the insurer’s own rate decisions. KFF found average premiums rose 7% from 2024 to 2025. If your increase feels large, you can compare the same plan letter from other insurers or ask about the Illinois Birthday Law if you are 65 to 75.
Can I switch Medigap plans in Illinois?
Yes, but approval can depend on timing. During your six-month open enrollment period, insurers must sell you a policy without underwriting. Later, the Birthday Law lets people 65 to 75 move to an equal or lesser plan with the same company during a 45-day window each year (Medicare Choices Guide for 2026).
Sources
- Get Medigap costs, Medicare.gov
- Costs, Medicare.gov (2026)
- Key Facts About Medigap Enrollment and Premiums, KFF
- Medigap guide for the Chicago area, Illinois SHIP
- Medicare Choices Guide for 2026, Illinois Department on Aging
- Medigap premiums report, ASPE/HHS
- Medigap Open Enrollment state summary chart, NAIC
- Medicare and fibromyalgia: coverage for testing explained